The Wheel of Time: 11. Knife of Dreams by Robert Jordan
The following review is only going to be of use to those who have already started to read The Wheel of Time. I'm certainly not going to recommend the series to anyone new until it's completed (I just don't have the faith any more), so those who don't have a passing acquaintance with Robert Jordan's work might want to skip this.
I view a new Wheel of Time book with a lot of trepidation these days. Since book 7 (A Crown of Swords) the books have, frankly, been rubbish, the only standout moment being the climax of book 9 (Winter's Heart) because after 2000-odd pages of describing red-slashed riding dresses or neatly trimmed and oiled beards something actually happened. I hadn't planned on buying book 11 until it was out in paperback. Book 10 (Crossroads of Twilight) damaged my faith to the point that I wasn't willing to shell out £20.
That said, I received the book in hardcover for Christmas, so I couldn't really complain. Before I got around to reading it, a really weird thing happened: I read a good review.
Truth is, this book is everything that the previous 4 should have been. The pace is reminiscent of the earlier novels -- the ones that got us all hooked in the first place -- when the story was driven by things happening rather than women sniffing and feelings being transmitted through warder bonds. Things happen in this book. There is action, and in the second half of the book that action is relentless.
Perhaps the most amazing thing about this book is that, after so much stalling, several of the minor plot lines are resolved. I can think of four or five off the top of my head. And that is something that should encourage those disenchanted fans to keep reading.
For the first time in a long time, there's a glimmer of hope that a). this will end well, and b). this will end some time before we all die of old age.
There are a couple of complaints, of course. Firstly being that after a good (if stupidly long) prologue, Jordan does slip back into his old habits for a while, and some of the chapters written through minor viewpoints (I'm thinking the aes sedai, mainly) are a real struggle.
Secondly, there are so many characters now that it's difficult keeping track of them. Jordan must have identified and described a hundred aes sedai by now, not to mention dozens of nobels, asha'man, etc. Without the help of an appendix -- such as provided by George RR Martin in his Song of Ice and Fire series -- remembering everyone is impossible.
Thirdly, and this is a personal gripe, one of the plot arcs that is hinted at isn't resolved, and I really want to know what happens in that one. It's for this reason that I think that there are another couple of books to come, if not more.
So, to the fans my advice is: stick with it. To new readers: avoid like the plague, at least until the end is written.
#
50 book challenge 2006:
1 = The Soldier's Son Trilogy: 1. Shaman's Crossing by Robin Hobb [review]
2 = The Wheel of Time: 11. Knife of Dreams by Robert Jordan
Next = Conclave of the Shadows: 3. Exile's Return by Raymond E Fiest